Aurora vs Newmarket

Should You Buy in York Region or Durham Region? 2026 Guide

If you’re considering a move outside Toronto, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is this:

Should you buy in York Region or Durham Region?

Both regions offer strong value compared to Toronto, growing communities, and family-friendly neighbourhoods. But they are very different markets — in pricing, lifestyle, commute patterns, and long-term investment potential.

This guide breaks down the real differences so you can decide what fits your goals.

Home Prices: Where Do You Get More for Your Money?

In general:

  • York Region commands higher prices.

  • Durham Region offers more square footage for less money.

If your budget is under $800K, Durham may offer:

  • Detached homes in some towns

  • Larger lots

  • Newer subdivisions

In York Region, that same budget may mean:

  • Townhomes

  • Smaller detached homes

  • Condo townhouses in prime locations

If your budget is $900K–$1M+, York Region opens up significantly and becomes more competitive.

Commute & Accessibility

York Region generally offers:

  • Faster access to Highway 404 and 400 corridors

  • Multiple GO Transit stations

  • Strong transit links to Toronto’s north end

Durham Region:

  • Strong access via Highway 401

  • GO stations along the Lakeshore East line

  • Commute times increase the farther east you go

If daily commuting is important, proximity to transit should heavily influence your choice.

Lifestyle & Community Feel

York Region

  • More established suburban infrastructure

  • Higher density in certain municipalities

  • Strong retail and commercial development

  • Highly competitive school zones

Major municipalities include:

  • Richmond Hill

  • Markham

  • Aurora

  • Newmarket

Durham Region

  • More rural-to-suburban mix

  • Newer communities expanding rapidly

  • Larger lots in some towns

  • Quieter, less dense overall

Major municipalities include:

  • Whitby

  • Oshawa

  • Clarington

  • Pickering

York Region feels more “mature suburban.” Durham often feels more “growing suburban.”

Long-Term Investment Potential

Historically:

  • York Region has shown stronger price stability.

  • Durham has shown stronger percentage growth during expansion cycles.

York Region tends to:

  • Hold value during slower markets

  • Recover faster after corrections

Durham tends to:

  • Experience sharper growth in hot markets

  • Experience sharper slowdowns in balanced markets

Neither is “better.” They behave differently.


Schools & Family Considerations

York Region has:

  • Highly competitive public and Catholic school zones

  • Strong international reputation in certain communities

  • High demand driven by school rankings

Durham Region:

  • Strong local school options

  • Less competition-driven pricing in many neighbourhoods

If school ranking priority is extremely high, York Region often commands premium pricing.

Property Taxes & Carrying Costs

Durham municipalities may have slightly lower property taxes in some areas.

However:

  • Insurance

  • Utilities

  • Maintenance

  • Condo fees

… can vary significantly by property type in both regions.

Lower purchase price does not always mean lower total monthly cost.

Who Should Choose York Region?

York Region may be a better fit if you:

  • Work in North Toronto

  • Prioritize school zones

  • Want strong long-term stability

  • Prefer mature suburban infrastructure

  • Have a budget above entry-level thresholds

Who Should Choose Durham Region?

  • Durham Region may be a better fit if you:

    • Want maximum space for your budget

    • Prefer newer developments

    • Work east of Toronto

    • Are comfortable with a longer commute

    • Want a quieter suburban feel

2026 Market Reality

In today’s balanced market:

  • York Region offers stability.

  • Durham Region offers affordability.

The “right” choice depends less on headlines and more on:

  • Your budget

  • Your commute

  • Your lifestyle goals

  • Your long-term plans

Final Thoughts

There is no universal answer to “York vs Durham.”

It’s about alignment.

Some buyers value stability and proximity. Others value space and price.

If you’re unsure which region fits your goals, I’m happy to walk you through:

  • Current pricing by property type

  • Monthly carrying cost comparisons

  • School zone breakdowns

  • Investment outlook differences

  • Commute mapping

Every move should be strategic — not reactive.

Ready When You Are

No pressure. Just a conversation.

If you’re thinking about buying or selling — now or later — I’m happy to answer questions and help you understand your options.


This website may only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate of the type being offered via the website. The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of the PropTx MLS®. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate.