Old Town Newmarket Homes for Sale
Old Town Newmarket Listings
Old Town Newmarket is one of the area’s most established and walkable neighbourhoods, known for its tree-lined streets, character homes, and close connection to Main Street. With a mix of historic properties and thoughtfully updated homes, it appeals to buyers who value charm, community, and everyday convenience. Easy access to shops, dining, and local events makes this area a standout choice for those looking to enjoy a more connected lifestyle.
-
431 Eagle Street in Newmarket: Central Newmarket House for sale : MLS®# N13868664
431 Eagle Street Newmarket L3Y 1K5 
$779,000Residential Freehold- Status:
- Active
- MLS® Num:
- N13868664
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 2
Step into the warmth and character of this charming century home, where timeless architectural details blend beautifully with today's modern conveniences. From the moment you enter the front foyer, you'll appreciate the rich hardwood floors, classic wood trim, and stunning staircase that showcase the home's enduring craftsmanship. The main floor living area is accented with wooden shelves flanking the main window overlooking the front porch; while a connected Dining space offers a formal space for entertaining. The kitchen features updated granite counters to modernize the space along with a separate pantry and a generous eat-in space. Step into the sunroom, insulated for 3 season use, also works well as a year round workout room. Two second floor bedrooms share a 4 piece bathroom featuring a timeless clawfoot tub. Separate garage gives you flexible space for a car or storage and workshop. Side entry to the home direct to the basement or kitchen for convenience. Incredible walkability location. More detailsListed by KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY CENTRES- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
A 487 Eagle Street in Newmarket: Central Newmarket House for lease : MLS®# N13553118
A 487 Eagle Street Newmarket L3Y 1K7
$2,500Residential Freehold- Status:
- For Lease
- MLS® Num:
- N13553118
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 1
Tucked into one of central Newmarket's most established and family-friendly residential pockets, 487 Eagle Street puts you close to everything the town has to offer. Fitness and recreation are practically at your doorstep, with the Ray Twinney Recreation Complex - home to an arena, pool, and fitness facilities. From here, historic Main Street Newmarket is just a short trip away, offering charming heritage storefronts, independent restaurants, cafes, and pubs. Outdoor lovers will appreciate nearby Fairy Lake Park and the scenic Tom Taylor Trail, while Riverwalk Commons hosts community events, markets, and seasonal festivities throughout the year. Everyday convenience is covered too: Upper Canada Mall - one of the GTA's largest shopping centres - is just a short drive north on Yonge Street, alongside a wide range of grocery, dining, and retail options. Commuters and healthcare workers alike will value the proximity to Southlake Regional Health Centre, one of the region's major hospitals and employers. Getting around is easy. Newmarket GO Station and Viva rapid transit on Yonge Street and Davis Drive offer convenient transit into and around the GTA, while quick access to Highway 404 makes commuting by car simple, whether you're heading toward Toronto or exploring the rest of York Region. This bright, ground-floor 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom unit offers easy, no-stairs living with a comfortable layout and one dedicated parking space - a great perk in this convenient, sought-after location. More detailsListed by CENTURY 21 LEADING EDGE REALTY INC.- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
1 457 D'Arcy Street in Newmarket: Central Newmarket House for lease : MLS®# N14085532
1 457 D'Arcy Street Newmarket L3Y 1M9
$3,400Residential Freehold- Status:
- For Lease
- MLS® Num:
- N14085532
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 2
This Isn't Your Average Apartment-This Is Loft Living With Serious Character In A Beautifully Restored And Completely Renovated 1865 Heritage Building Known As The Ingham Sharpe House! With 12-Foot Soaring Ceilings, Oversized Windows, And A Modern Open Layout, This 2-Bed, 2-Bath Space Strikes The Perfect Balance Between Historic Charm And Stylish Modern Updates. The Kitchen And Bathrooms Are Sleek And Fresh, And The Entire Space Feels Airy, Bright, Carpet-Free, And Ideally Suited For Both Relaxation And Entertaining. Top-Rated Appliances, Exclusive Laundry Machines. Utilities, Parking, Snow Removal, And Lawn Maintenance Included! Best Of All, You're In The Heart Of Downtown Newmarket's Entertainment District-Just Steps From Historic Main St, Fairy Lake Park, Live Entertainment, Coffee Shops, Breweries, Bars, Top-Rated Restaurants, And Newmarket's Flea Market. Enjoy Walkable, Vibrant Living. Conveniently Close To Public Transit, The GO Train, Schools, Southlake Hospital, Highway 404, And Other Key Amenities. More detailsListed by SUTTON GROUP-ADMIRAL REALTY INC.- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
# 1 443 Timothy Street in Newmarket: Central Newmarket House for lease : MLS®# N13120590
# 1 443 Timothy Street Newmarket L3Y 1P7
$2,300Residential Freehold- Status:
- For Lease
- MLS® Num:
- N13120590
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
Beautiful Large One Bedroom Apartment with Open Concept Living Area In The Heart Of Newmarket. Includes A Custom Kitchen, Granite Counters, Large 4 Pc EnSuite Bathroom. Large Double Closet. Large Above Ground Windows . Laminate Flooring. Coin Laundry. All Units Have Own Furnace, Air Conditioner, H.W.Tank. Metered Separately. Minutes To Fairy Lake, Farmers Market, Public Transit, Restaurants, Banks. NO PETS ALLOWED. NO SMOKING/VAPING. Please attach all documents, Sch B etc. More detailsListed by REMAX YOUR COMMUNITY REALTY- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
203 400 Park Avenue in Newmarket: Central Newmarket Condo Apartment for sale : MLS®# N13765786
203 400 Park Avenue Newmarket L3Y 1V8
$589,999Residential Condo & Other- Status:
- Active
- MLS® Num:
- N13765786
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
Welcome To The King George School Lofts!*This Stunning 1 Bedroom Loft Offers South/West Views Just Steps to Historic Downtown Newmarket, You Truly Can't Beat The Location!*This Beautifully Designed Unit Showcases Soaring 12'8" Ceilings, Rich Hardwood Flooring, Oversized Windows And An Elegant Open-Concept Layout Filled With Natural Light Throughout*The Kitchen Is Thoughtfully Appointed With Quartz Countertops, A Freestanding Centre Island, And Full-Size Stainless Steel Appliances, Making It Ideal For Both Everyday Living And Entertaining*The 4 Piece Bathroom Is Finished With Marble, Adding Another Touch Of Luxury To The Space*Freshly Painted And Loaded With Upgrades, This Unit Includes Automatic Window Coverings, Custom Built-In Cabinetry, Oversized Closets, And An Abundance Of Storage Throughout*Enjoy The Convenience Of In-Suite Laundry And An Owned, Covered Parking Space*Located In An Unbeatable Area Close To Main Street's Shops, Restaurants, Cafes, And All Amenities That This Sought-After Area Offers*This Exceptional Loft Is Perfect For Those Seeking Style, Comfort, And Convenience In A Prime Location!*Don't Miss It! More detailsListed by RE/MAX HALLMARK YORK GROUP REALTY LTD.- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
304 400 Park Avenue in Newmarket: Central Newmarket Condo Apartment for sale : MLS®# N14082290
304 400 Park Avenue Newmarket L3Y 1V8
$849,900Residential Condo & Other- Status:
- Active
- MLS® Num:
- N14082290
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 2
Stunning 2 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Loft Condo in the Sought-After King George School House Lofts in the Heart of Historic Downtown Newmarket* Rare Opportunity to Own a Beautifully Designed 1220 Sq Ft Suite Featuring Soaring 12'8" Ceilings and Rich Hardwood Flooring Creating a Bright, Open Concept Layout Filled with Natural Light* Modern Kitchen with Upgraded Finishes, Quartz Countertops, Stainless Steel Appliances, and an Abundance of Cabinetry & Counter Space-Perfect for Everyday Living and Entertaining* Spacious Living Area with Functional Open Concept Design* Large Primary Bedroom Featuring a Walk-In Closet with Custom Organizers and a Private Ensuite Bathroom with Elegant, Upgraded Finishes* Second Bedroom Generously Sized with Great Natural Light, a Double Closet, and a Semi-Ensuite Bathroom* Both Bathrooms Beautifully Finished with Modern, Upgraded Details* Includes Covered Surface Parking Space for Added Convenience* Located in One of Newmarket's Most Desirable Neighbourhoods, Just Steps to Historic Main Street, Shops, Restaurants, Southlake Hospital, GO Train Station, Parks, and All Amenities-Perfect for Those Seeking a Vibrant and Convenient Downtown Lifestyle* More detailsListed by CENTURY 21 HERITAGE GROUP LTD.- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
403 Park Avenue in Newmarket: Central Newmarket House for sale : MLS®# N13883596
403 Park Avenue Newmarket L3Y 1V7
$1,099,999Residential Freehold- Status:
- Active
- MLS® Num:
- N13883596
- Bedrooms:
- 4
- Bathrooms:
- 2
Welcome to 403 Park Ave, a character-filled property in the heart of Central Newmarket, just steps from historic Main Street, Fairy Lake, parks, shops, restaurants and everyday amenities. This versatile property is currently configured as two separate living spaces, each with its own entrance, offering an excellent opportunity for investors, multi-generational families, or buyers looking to create a home that fits their needs.Featuring approximately 2,216 sq. ft. of living space with 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, the home offers generous principal rooms, plenty of natural light and the charm and character you would expect from a property of this vintage. The flexible layout also provides the potential to reimagine the property as a spacious single-family home.Set on a mature lot in one of Newmarket's most established neighbourhoods, this is an opportunity to own a distinctive property in an exceptional downtown location with convenient access to transit, schools, recreation and all that Main Street Newmarket has to offer. More detailsListed by RIGHT AT HOME REALTY- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
207 543 Timothy Street in Newmarket: Central Newmarket Condo Apartment for sale : MLS®# N13751834
207 543 Timothy Street Newmarket L3Y 1R1
$590,000Residential Condo & Other- Status:
- Active
- MLS® Num:
- N13751834
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
Welcome to Timothy Street Lofts, where industrial character meets everyday comfort. This one-bedroom, one-bathroom loft is a standout in the building - offering two parking spots, a rare find for a one-bedroom, along with western exposure that fills the space with afternoon light and sunset views. This 699 square foot unit features soaring ceilings, exposed beams and ductwork, and an open-concept layout that gives the space an airy, lofty-like feel. The kitchen offers granite counters & stainless steel appliances, flowing into a bright living and dining area perfect for both relaxing and entertaining. Steps to Main Street Newmarket's shops and restaurants, the Tom Taylor Trail and Fairy Lake, with easy access to the GO train and hospital. Everything downtown Newmarket has to offer is right outside your door. Maintenance fees include, water, sewage, heat, hydro, cable and internet. More detailsListed by ROYAL LEPAGE RCR REALTY- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
106 543 Timothy Street in Newmarket: Central Newmarket Condo Apartment for sale : MLS®# N13838682
106 543 Timothy Street Newmarket L3Y 1R1 OPEN HOUSE: Oct 24, 202601:00 PM - 03:00 PM EDTOpen House on Saturday, October 24, 2026 1:00PM - 3:00PM
$699,900Residential Condo & Other- Status:
- Active
- MLS® Num:
- N13838682
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 2
Timothy St Loft's Redesigned by Aspen & Ivy where Modern Charm Meets Urban Luxury! This Large 2 Bedroom Unit boasts Incredible Western, Ravine & City Views! Soaring 13'+ Ceilings with exposed Beams and Mechanicals for a Bright Trendy Vibe. Welcome to Unit 106 - A private, main floor & corner unit - Units like this one rarely come available! Two (2) Parking Spots & Locker are included. Condo Fees Include All Utilities (Water, Gas, Hydro) + Cable/ Fiber Optic Internet! Open Concept Floor Plan with approx 1,025 Square Feet of Luxury Living Space. Modern Eat-In Kitchen with Stainless Steel Appliances, Breakfast Bar & Quartz Counters. Spacious Primary Bedroom with Huge Walk In Closet & En Suite bath. Second Bedroom also has a Walk In Closet. Modern Laminate Flooring, Fresh Paint & Updated Light Fixtures Throughout. NEW Custom Window Coverings with Remote/ Power Shades in the Living Room. Barn Door Features. Ample Storage. Soak in the sunsets & tons of natural light! Located In the heart of Downtown Newmarket W/ Convenient Access To All Amenities Just Steps Away Including The Tom Taylor Trail, Fairy Lake, Main Street Newmarket Shops, Restaurants & So Much More! Walk to Go Train & Hospital. Amenities Include: Gym, Theatre Room, Terrace On The 2nd Floor W/Bbq's, Party Room, Lounge Area. More detailsListed by RE/MAX HALLMARK CHAY REALTY- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
419 Millard Avenue in Newmarket: Central Newmarket House for sale : MLS®# N14103682
419 Millard Avenue Newmarket L3Y 2A2
$465,000Residential Freehold- Status:
- Active
- MLS® Num:
- N14103682
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 2
**Attention Investors, Renovators & Builders!** Opportunity to own a detached 2-storey home in the established Central Newmarket neighbourhood. Situated on a corner lot, this vacant property offers 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, an unfinished partial basement and a detached garage. Conveniently located near Historic Main Street, Fairy Lake, parks, schools, shopping, restaurants and local amenities. **Property is being sold strictly in "As-Is, Where-Is" condition** and requires substantial repairs and renovations, Not currently move-in ready. Ideal for experienced buyers prepared to undertake extensive improvements, subject to municipal approvals where applicable. Buyers are encouraged to conduct their own due diligence regarding property condition, repairs, permits and intended use. An opportunity to restore or reimagine this property in a mature Newmarket community. More detailsListed by RE/MAX ACE REALTY INC.- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
103 Arden Avenue in Newmarket: Central Newmarket House for sale : MLS®# N14104770
103 Arden Avenue Newmarket L3Y 4H7
$1,049,000Residential Freehold- Status:
- Active
- MLS® Num:
- N14104770
- Bedrooms:
- 5
- Bathrooms:
- 3
Welcome to 103 Arden Avenue, a charming detached 2.5-storey Century Home situated on a 43' x 98' lot in Central Newmarket. Offering 2,479 sq. ft. above grade, this spacious home features 4 bedrooms, a covered front porch and a long private driveway. The versatile loft offers additional space ideal for a home office, playroom, den or bonus living area. Enjoy an updated kitchen featuring all new appliances, along with updated electrical completed with an ESA permit. A unique opportunity to own a character-filled home with modern updates in a convenient location. *Washer and dryer to be installed. Heat pump and A/C to be installed on the third floor.* More detailsListed by HOMELIFE SUPERSTARS REAL ESTATE LIMITED- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
-
422 Queen Street in Newmarket: Central Newmarket House for sale : MLS®# N13757500
422 Queen Street Newmarket L3Y 2H2 OPEN HOUSE: Oct 24, 202612:00 PM - 02:00 PM EDTOpen House on Saturday, October 24, 2026 12:00PM - 2:00PM
$849,000Residential Freehold- Status:
- Active
- MLS® Num:
- N13757500
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 1
Open-concept charming bungalow in the heart of Olde Newmarket, just steps from the vibrant bars and restaurants of Main Street, beautiful Fairy Lake, Southlake Hospital, and the GO Train. It simply doesn't get better than this! Situated in the historic heart of Newmarket, yet with NO heritage protection, offering added flexibility for future plans. Whether you're a first-time buyer, investor, or looking for the perfect place to retire, this is an incredible opportunity to own in one of Newmarket's most sought-after locations! Recent upgrades to the home; newly finished basement, roof, fence, 240-volt electrical supply, electric car charger, gas line for BBQ, Hot Water Tank (2026), Water Softener (2026) More detailsListed by REMAX YOUR COMMUNITY REALTY- DORI ROMANTINI
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
- 1 (647) 2016397
- Contact by Email
Data was last updated October 22, 2026 at 03:15 AM (UTC)
Clear Guidance for Buying & Selling Real Estate Across York Region & Durham
Office Address:
1550 Sixteenth Avenue, Building B, Units 3, 4
Richmond Hill, ON, L4B 3K9